📄
System Markdown Documents Library
Centralized registry to read, inspect, and edit every Markdown document across the entire Utilis system.
Document Index (39)
All Files
Tier 4 Global Doctrines
3
Role Work Loop Contracts
8
README-LOOP: Journalist
29576b
README-LOOP-journalist.md
README-LOOP: Fact Checker
2956b
README-LOOP-fact_checker.md
README-LOOP: Researcher
2835b
README-LOOP-researcher.md
README-LOOP: News Aggregator
2439b
README-LOOP-news_aggregator.md
README-LOOP: Taxonomy Classifier
2564b
README-LOOP-worldview_classifier.md
README-LOOP: AI-Text Scorer / Rewriter
2632b
README-LOOP-ai_text_scorer_rewriter.md
README-LOOP: Generalist
2497b
README-LOOP-generalist.md
README-LOOP: Universal Five-Stage Pipeline (Legacy)
4526b
README-LOOP-legacy-5stage.md
Agent README Specifications
10
README-AGENT: Overall Shift (Slot 1)
12361b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-1-0c45ee.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 2 (Slot 2)
7087b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-2.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 3 (Slot 3)
5626b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-3.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 4 (Slot 4)
5637b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-4.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 5 (Slot 5)
4463b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-5.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 6 (Slot 6)
5467b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-6.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 7 (Slot 7)
5462b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-7.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 8 (Slot 8)
5456b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-8.md
README-AGENT: Council Member 9 (Slot 9)
4495b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-9.md
README-AGENT: New News Aggregator (Slot 10) (Slot 10)
4296b
README-AGENT-ag-slot-10-beb197.md
Agent Dedicated Context & Research
15
01 PROMPT-AGENT-1-Overall-Shift
20263b
PROMPT-AGENT-1-Overall-Shift.md
The Shift Analyst — Primary Context Charter
654b
AGENT_01_SHIFT_ANALYST_CONTEXT.md
01 CTX-AGENT-1-OVERALL-SHIFT (Foundational Research Library)
20263b
CTX-AGENT-1-OVERALL-SHIFT.md
CTX-AGENT-1-OVERALL-SHIFT
104205b
CTX-AGENT-1-OVERALL-SHIFT.md
PROMPT-AGENT-2-Human-Impact
18381b
PROMPT-AGENT-2-Human-Impact.md
CTX-AGENT-2-HUMAN-IMPACT
87754b
CTX-AGENT-2-HUMAN-IMPACT.md
The Human Condition Analyst — Primary Context Charter
484b
AGENT_02_HUMAN_CONDITION_CONTEXT.md
The Institutions and Power Analyst — Primary Context Charter
451b
AGENT_03_INSTITUTIONS_POWER_CONTEXT.md
The Machine Intelligence Analyst — Primary Context Charter
449b
AGENT_04_MACHINE_INTELLIGENCE_CONTEXT.md
The Fact Checker — Primary Context Charter
499b
AGENT_05_FACT_CHECKER_CONTEXT.md
The Classifier (Uli AI) — Primary Context Charter
567b
AGENT_06_CLASSIFIER_CONTEXT.md
Economic & Labor Metrics Specialist — Primary Context Charter
129b
AGENT_07_LABOR_ECONOMICS_CONTEXT.md
Sovereign & Geopolitical AI Analyst — Primary Context Charter
147b
AGENT_08_GEOPOLITICS_CONTEXT.md
Human Authorship & Meaning Analyst — Primary Context Charter
138b
AGENT_09_MEANING_AUTHORSHIP_CONTEXT.md
Executive Synthesis & Counter-Thesis Copilot — Primary Context Charter
145b
AGENT_10_SYNTHESIS_CONTEXT.md
Company & Workspace Guardrails
2
Council Architecture Matrix
1
README-LOOP: Universal Five-Stage Pipeline (Legacy)
README-LOOP-legacy-5stage.md
•
Category: Role Work Loop Contracts
•
Size: 4526 bytes
Deactivated Pipeline Trace Reference
Storage:
data/workflows/README-LOOP.md
# README-LOOP: Five-Stage Council Editorial State Machine
**Governance:** System State Machine Specification (Lead Prompt Architect)
**Target Architecture:** 10-Slot Multi-Agent Deliberative Editorial Council
**Primary Execution Models:** Qwen 2.5 Coder 32B Instruct / Qwen 2.5 72B Instruct (Zero Paid API Spend)
**Generated / Synchronized:** 2026-10-30T18:46:34Z
---
## 1. Overview & Core Philosophy
The Utilis Council Workflow is a deterministic, five-stage state machine that guides analytical opinion generation from initial intake to human editorial sign-off. It strictly enforces temporal context isolation, role boundaries, and human editorial governance.
```mermaid
flowchart TD
A["Stage 1: Independent Initial Assessment"] --> B["Stage 2: Evidence Sufficiency Evaluation"]
B -->|SUFFICIENT| D["Stage 4: Position Reconciliation"]
B -->|RESEARCH_REQUIRED| C{"Human Editor Approval Gate"}
C -->|Approved & Delegated| C1["Stage 3: Specialist Collaboration & Research"]
C -->|Rejected| D
C1 -->|Deliverable Recorded| D
D --> E["Stage 5: Fact-Check Audit & Memory Checkpoint"]
E --> F{"Human Publication Gate"}
F -->|Signed Off| G["Utilis CMS Publication"]
```
## 2. Stage Breakdown & Execution Rules
### Stage 1: Independent Initial Assessment
- **Purpose:** Produces an untainted first-pass analytical stance grounded strictly in the assigned brief and source evidence.
- **Trigger:** Commission of an Editorial Assignment with focus intake articles.
- **Required Context:** Tier 1 & 2 Guardrails, Tier 5 Charter & 6 Diagnostic Inquiries, Tier 3 Taxonomy Whitelist (19 concepts), Tier 4 Workspace Doctrine, Focus Intake items (`<untrusted_evidence>`).
- **Strict Exclusions:** All historical opinions from prior assignments (prevents groupthink and premature consensus); peer agent deliberations; specialist research.
- **Exit Condition:** Formatted Initial Assessment output; advances automatically to Stage 2.
### Stage 2: Evidence Sufficiency Evaluation
- **Purpose:** Evaluates whether the factual evidence in Stage 1 is robust and corroborated, or whether critical data gaps exist.
- **Trigger:** Successful completion of Stage 1.
- **Decision Types:**
- `SUFFICIENT`: Evidence supports thesis $\to$ proceeds directly to Stage 4.
- `RESEARCH_REQUIRED`: Critical gap identified $\to$ generates structured research inquiry and enters `WAITING_FOR_RESEARCH` state.
- **Stop Condition:** Pipeline halts safely in `WAITING_FOR_RESEARCH` until human editor intervenes.
### Stage 3: Specialist Collaboration & Research (CONDITIONAL)
- **Important Rule:** Specialist research is **conditional**, never mandatory. It is executed ONLY when Stage 2 yields `RESEARCH_REQUIRED` AND the Human Editor approves delegation.
- **Execution:** Assigned specialist (e.g. Labor Economist Slot 7, Geopolitics Slot 8, or Market Researcher) conducts targeted investigation.
- **Deliverable:** Recorded as structured `Commons` deliverable with supporting citations.
- **Exit Condition:** Deliverable recorded; assigned guardian is notified and pipeline resumes into Stage 4.
### Stage 4: Position Reconciliation
- **Purpose:** Re-evaluates initial stance against specialist deliverables and prior genuine consensus opinions.
- **Required Context:** Stage 1 Assessment, Stage 3 Specialist Deliverables, Prior Latest-Version Approved Consensus Opinions, Tier 4 Doctrine.
- **Exclusions:** Quarantined test opinions (`op-live-*`), cross-agent private scratchpads.
- **Exit Condition:** Produces reconciled opinion explicitly marked `MAINTAINED` or `REVISED` with comparative rationale.
### Stage 5: Fact-Check Audit & Memory Checkpoint
- **Purpose:** Slot 5 (Fact Checker) verifies factual statements and quotations against primary sources.
- **Action:** Upon verification, records a durable memory checkpoint to `agent_working_memory` with `ACTIVE` status.
- **Final Gate:** Activates human publication sign-off in Utilis CMS. **AI agents cannot publish autonomously.**
## 3. Failure Modes, Escalation & Stop Conditions
1. **Ungrounded Evidence:** Triggers Stage 2 `RESEARCH_REQUIRED` pause.
2. **Model Timeout / Failure:** Maximum 2 retries with exponential backoff before flagging assignment as `ERROR_SUSPENDED`.
3. **Cross-Talk Violation:** Prompt boundary wrapping prevents unauthorized inter-agent instruction injection.
4. **Audit Trail:** Every stage generates an immutable Context Manifest and, when enabled, an immutable Captured Model Payload in `agent_payload_captures`.